top of page

Theodore L. Cuyler: The Pastor Who Came to the Door.

Beyond the Sunday sermon

A sermon ended, but the pastor’s work did not. Theodore L. Cuyler kept track of where his people lived. He asked to hear when someone moved, when sickness entered a home, or when a family needed help. In his autobiography, those ordinary details become part of the story of a ministry.

The address mattered because a person lived there. The visit mattered because the trouble would still be there after Sunday.

A ministry close to people

Cuyler became the first pastor of Brooklyn’s Lafayette Avenue Presbyterian Church in April 1860 and served until Easter 1890. Looking back, he described pastoral visiting as a particular joy. He wanted to know his congregation and be at home among them.

That concern gives his practical writing its setting. How to Be a Pastor belongs beside an open Bible and the everyday responsibilities of caring for people. His life reminds us to ask what happens after a message has been heard: who will return, who needs encouragement, and who has not yet been noticed?

A Life in Brief

1822 — Born; the autobiographer grew up in Aurora, New York.

1860 — Began his Lafayette Avenue Presbyterian Church pastorate.

1890 — Concluded that pastorate at Easter.

1902 — Published Recollections of a Long Life.

1909 — Died.

Books and Writings

How to Be a Pastor (Digital Editions)

  • Other selected writings:

  • Recollections of a Long Life (1902) — autobiography.
    God’s Light on Dark Clouds.
    Heart Life.

  • Source: Cuyler’s Recollections of a Long Life.

bottom of page